Islam Readings

For today we read 3 readings on Islam (2 by Tariq Ramadan and 1 by Ali Shari'ati).

I didn't really like the reading by Shariati because it seemed to blame the situation of third world countries and the Middle East solely on Western capitalism and culture it carries with it.

I contend that this is a dramatic oversimplification of the reality of events. While those in power may have misused Western ideas and forced them upon the inhabitants in many situations, I argue that many Western ideas can improve the quality of life and not damage pre-existing cultures.

I am also critical of his characterization of Western culture as a homogeneous entity. There is more variation and flexibility than he seems to acknowledge.

Sorry I couldn't cover everything we read in this post. I'll try to cover more on Saturday or Monday.